I'm hoping to bang out a quick post here, including embedding some videos I'm sure I've shared before. So let's get to it.
Many years ago, Stephen Fry was hosting BBC program "QI" whose tweely named "elves" had caught up to the quite interesting subject of the Dunning Kruger effect and it culminated in Fry asking the panel "how do you know if you are incompetent?"
Now the answer is, that you can't, and this isn't what this post is about. It is about what it feels like to be incompetent, and for that I turn to Japanese motion picture tradition of portraying martial arts onscreen. Starting with the climactic battle of Sanjuro, Akira Kurosawa's follow up to Yojimbo which Sergio Leone used unapologetically for the basis of "A Fistful of Dollars.":
Now I can't speak for you, but speaking for myself, I've watched this scene at least a dozen times and each time I experience it as not being able to perceive what happened. How does Sanjuro, the one with the long sideburns played by Toshiro Mifune, manage to draw his sword and kill the opponent?
If you watch it on youtube, you can slow down playback speed in settings to see that it comes down to an economy of movement on the victors part, hence he can appear to draw late/second but win the duel. This however, it should be kept in mind, is still illusion. Choreography, plus an effect that actually was a mechanical failure causing the blood to spray rather than trickle, that Kurosawa decided to keep in the final cut and has subsequently become a trope of Japanese animated films and even video games.
But don't get too absorbed in that trivia, I want to move us along to what I keep coming back to in terms of masterfully capturing, what I at least, feel like when incompetent. I'm talking Mugen vs Kariya in Samurai Champloo:
Now, if you need the context this is one of the ultimate match-ups in the whole series of Samurai Champloo, and the guy who comes across as a completely outclassed rank-amateur in the above clip has previously been established as one of the strongest martial artists in the entire fictitious universe. Almost a scene using the trope of the Worf effect.
But if it is, and it certainly is a candidate because Kariya kind of comes out of knowhere, a literal ringer adversary for the plot, it is done masterfully.
What I love is that Kariya is one of the visually least-interesting character designs in the whole animated series. Compared to Mugen with his unusual clothes and hair, pirate cutlass style sword and reinforced wooden sandles, Kariya wears drab browns, looks like he's in his autumn years and has no impressive physique and all of the visual interest comes from what he does.
Or rather...how the animators convey his character through visuals.
What I keep thinking about are the slo-mo sequences where Kariya's prowess is presented from Mugen's perspective, as supernatural powers. Mugen loses track of Kariya's sword movements first, but we experience this as the sword vanishing, then reappearing at an impossibly different angle in our peripheral vision. A magic sword? Or does Mugen simply not understand what is happening?
Then I love the nice touch of the switched perspective, where Mugen conceales himself behind the sacks of what I assume to be beans, and starts tossing them at Kariya. We get Kariyas perspective and nothing supernatural is happening at all. In fact we just impassively watch Mugen reappear through a smoke screen of beans to be easily dodges and sent sprawling.
Then it is back to Mugen's experience, and you can see it but we get some strange sequence where the opponents trade places, and at first we get some ambiguous visual effects that allude to Mugen finding something strange about Kariya's movements, then the most supernatural effect where Kariya seemingly turns into a ghost, like those white guys with dreadlocks in the Matrix: Reloaded, and passes bodily through Mugen before ending the fight dismissively.
This to me, is what I would point to if asked "what does it feel like to be incompetent?"
It feels spooky, confusing, unsettling. It feels to me, like what Mugen is seeing fighting Kariya. Unlike with the live action Sanjuro, slowing it down will yield no insight, though we can imagine getting a third parties perspective on the conflict and I would assume - we do not see Kariya teleport his sword out of his hands, and we do not see Kariya turn into a ghost and pass through Mugen.
Indeed, once Jin starts fighting Kariya, these effects disappear, or at least become much more subtle. Kariya just seems to kind of teleport around the animation frames from where Jin attacks to where Jin isn't attacking.
Bringing me to Shane. Shane being a film where Alan Ladd plays the titular role, and Jack Palance plays the black hat muscle of the main antagonist. He is essentially brought in to town by the big rancher to kill off the collective of small-holders or "sodbusters" by goading them into drawing.
Shane's iconic quick draw scene between Palance's character and Stonewall, captures for me the scary reality of being incompetent - which is that incompetence can terrifyingly not feel like anything at all until it is too late, where we might get a couple of seconds at most to feel confusion and remorse, certainly not in any intelligible capacity:
Mugen is clearly just dumb-lucky to get to walk away from his fight with Kariya alive. And let's face it, outside of interacting with lethal amounts of momentum - ie. vehicles and heavy equipment, most of our incompetence in the modern era doesn't manifest in life-or-death situations. (At least not for us directly.)
I experience it in things like personal interractions, where I am left with a vague uneasiness that something I said was the wrong thing to say.
Perhaps an easy context to explore it through is the job interview. Until recently, there were questions asked in job interviews, that I just don't understand why they are asked like "What are your salary expectations?" I had received the advice initially that the correct answer is "market rates." Which maywell work in a context like Australia, where we have government websites that allow us to find the award rate for various job categories.
I have since learned more about this question that frankly perplexed me, as in my experience I was typically interviewed for jobs that had advertised a salary. So why the fuck are you asking me? A question that confused me like Kariya's disappearing sword - I thought the ad said $55k? Am I supposed to ask for more? Am I supposed to say something less? I've heard some recruiters ask "what is the minimum salary you would accept?" That's even more confusing, because aren't I think tacitly agreeing already to accept the minimum?
I do not possess the competence now to give advice on how to answer the salary question. I think what most resonates with me is the general advice of - most job interviews are ultimately testing for preparation, so prepare by researching salaries like the aforementioned government website, the other general piece of advice is that if you are asked a direct question you should give a direct answer. People hate politicians.
Beyond that though, I am still incompetent. I would like to spend more time on the other side of the interview table to understand how this question is useful, why it cannot instead, for example, be a statement of salary expectations by the party that will be paying the salary.
It only makes sense in an executive capacity, where for example, Starbucks needs to figure out how to lure away the CEO of Chipotle to magically make them successful again like Chipotle. That situation it's like yeah - what would it take for you to come leave your job with a successful company to come work for a company that is going down the toilet?
But entry level positions at a bank? I don't get it. There's a bunch of clerks they already pay pretty much the same thing, and you are hiring another one onto the team. So you pretty much know what you are willing to pay, so why get me to guess what you pay from the outside? I am going to guess what you said in your ad. Is this a bait and switch? I can't tell because I am doing an interview with a video?
And this is probably what distinguishes the video clip from Shane, from the video clip from Yojimbo. In both cases, someone appears to draw first, but somehow too slowly. In Shane, it's even more brutal because there's this drawn out pause between losing the drawing contest, and getting shot.
But as a 3rd party, we get these clues as to how the duel is going to go. Jack Palance is standing on an elevated wooden walkway, the sodbuster Stonewall is standing and sometimes slipping in mud, at a clear disadvantage. Jack is insulting him, for some reason he can't just murder Stonewall, he needs Stonewall to draw, but he signals his intentions to murder Stonewall by putting on his shooting glove when they are both already in the position with feet planted ready for the duel. Stonewall could presumably still awkwardly walk away, all he has to do is not draw.
There's some kind of verbal dance going on and Jack Palance is in control of all of it. Stonewall conforms to his plan, likely because he just doesn't understand what is happening. It's kind of like when Charity muggers first started appearing in downtowns around the world, walking up and sticking out their hands to strangers asking in an inevitably British accent if we had a couple of minutes to chat about the environment.
The unfortunate thing about charity muggers, is that they were asking for $30 a month in direct debit payments to some ostensibly worthwhile cause presumptively addressed by a particular organization, instead of killing people with the cold psychopathy of Jack Palance's character. That could have continued for years, but instead people learned to turn cold and ignore their impulse to treat strangers with the benefit of the doubt, charity muggers successfully corroding the all important system of manners that holds society together.
Anyway, I've crapped on long enough and hopefully between job interviews and charity muggers, I've related the motion picture depictions of incompetence to real life experiences, and you will either share or not share, my subjective experience of being incompetent.
I've been thinking, as long time, or even one time, readers might assume I do, constantly, rendering this comma-laden opening sentence un-newsworthy; but let me get back to the follow on from that first ',': a lot about "C-students" recently.
But first I need to address an important point, people may assume this title to be a reference to the so-called "C-word" which is cunt, and I am a serious adult that may have grown up a short walk from numerous private schools, catholic schools and parklands and wetlands in Ballarat, but I got out enough to learn how to have "cunt" roll off my tongue without self-scandalizing at the appropriate age of however old kids are by grade-4 and I'm fucken proud of my Balifornian heritage and as such, need to make it clear that if you think I am alluding to cunts, you are mistaken, because if I'm alluding to a/some cunt(s), you will cunten-well know it.
And of course, my mid-90s heritage has no doubt turned off, via-ad-hominems some of the psychographic markets that would most benefit from hearing what I have to say from here out. But c'est-la-vie-cunts I guess. I am of course referring to the very common grading system in some primary schools and most prominently secondary schools the anglosphere over. "C" usually means a score of 50.
Now, a very safe way I could theoretically have introduced this concept is via the truistic heuristic:
"On average, people are average."
Which is to say, I may be above average in terms of something not very important like vocabulary, being someone who will eventually get the joke "eschew obscurantism" once it has been pointed out to me that it is meant to be a joke. And I'm probably now above average as-far as second language speakers of Japanese and Spanish are, but once you start adding "subjects" or fields of expertise, with the simple example of more languages like Mandarin, Cantonese, German, Italian, French, Greek, Vietnamese, Thai, Cambodian, Indonesian, Arabic, Pashtu, Finnish, Gaelic and Welsh etc. I conform to the global average - which is no ability at all to speak most languages.
The significance of C-students, is based on two qualities:
It is the minimum grade with which one can pass, to be deemed "sufficiently knowledgeable" or "competent" to require no further investment in that student.
It is the grade at which the ambiguity of what a student actually knows is maximised, because they know roughly half of the subject.
I wish to now expand upon this second point. If you know someone is a D-student in a given subject, then we know that they mostly don't understand the subject. Likewise, with a B-student, we know that they mostly know the subject. More extreme, with F and A students, we can be even more confident that they don't and do know most of the subject respectively. With a C-student though, for any given aspect of that subject they may or may not know what they are talking about with roughly the same odds as flipping a coin.
There is no doubt, some logic to our education systems setting the threshold of competence at 50%. This logic may however, go all the way back to the industrial revolution.
Furthermore, we should consider that in the context of education, there's a steady escalation of difficulty as kids progress K-12. Such that, a grade one student getting a C in maths (Australia, the commonwealth, cunts) may leave us guessing as to whether they can handle adding or subtracting, but a year 10 student getting a C in Math's methods leaves us guessing as to whether they struggle with locating asymptotes in quadratic equations or solving simultaneous equations (the latter, in my case, because of the bullshit 4 decimal answers that were supposedly "correct") but we can now safely assume that any and all students who've made it to year 10 maths methods, can handle adding, subtracting, multiplication and division by now, though they could still be fucking up BOMDAS/BODMAS (which if you are wondering, doing the division before the multiplication or vice versa is not the fuckup, forgetting either acronym is where they fuck up).
So it is now time to leave grade school as I did oh so long ago, in a place far away where the sensitive just had to flinch and cling to their "tuck shop" money when an exciting girl wearing Kappa pants on a bmx with poorly applied mascara and bleached hair with red-black regrowth asked if you were "a rich cunt" despite them having the $10 to spend on a pack of cigarettes from Poonie's milk-bar and $2.50 to spend on a 600ml bottle of coke that you wondered if they backwashed and wondered if they might abandon the last flat, luke-warm, saliva infused 50ml languishing in the 4 bevelled plastic nubs of the PET-adapted iconic rocket-ship bottle shape down by the tracks where a young man blushing uncontrollably as his limbic and endocrine system worked hard to confuse terror and arousal could somewhat one-sidedly experience the hygiene equivalent of kissing the terrifying and exciting girls from the other side of the tracks, because they were indeed "a rich cunt" and would never risk drinking the discarded dregs of coke because it most likely was discarded by a 50 year old man with a substance control problem where the substance was clearly not caffeine or sugar but some kind of amphetamine because they didn't finish their cokes.
Yes time to leave behind the good-old-days where girls didn't need tumblr memes or tik-tok influencers to convince them that doing their own "stick-and-poke" DIY underage tattoos were a good idea, and out into the real world. The fucken C-world.
The C-world
By which I mean it is simple. There are these shows I don't watch but have certainly heard about called "Dragon's Den" and "Shark Tank" where people present their ideas to wealthy investors hoping that some or all of the various sharks and dragons will invest in their idea to get their business off the ground or to the next level.
I propose a simple hypothetical exercise - have one of those arcade prize machine claws come down from the heavens, pick up the net worth of the sharks/dragons and have them deposit it on the Joe-nobodies that are pitching their business ideas of variable quality.
I predict two things will happen - the first is that more-than-zero of the contestants in suddenly becoming high-net-worth will discover they would not invest in their own ideas, and instead feel a sudden desire to talk to a financial planner about a diversified portfolio of stocks, bonds and real assets with a view to minimizing taxes.
The second thing will be that the Sharks and Dragons, suddenly devoid of any capital to invest in a startup will have to pitch investment ideas to random millionaires and their ideas are likely to be as rejectable as the average contestant.
Put simply, the pitching and catching relationship goes in the direction of people with no money to people with lots of money. The starting positions are unlikely to be based on meritocracy.
For the simplest example, just watch enough of Gordon Ramsey's Kitchen Nightmares. Not necessarily ubiquitous, but a very common thread through abysmally failing restaurants is that the people who own the restaurant try to run the restaurant.
There is a management adage you will almost certainly hear if you spend at least 90 days learning about management:
"I hire smart people and get out of their way". Lee Iacocca.
You may remember Lee from Ford vs. Ferrari, the guy that interferes with the race finish for publicity so Christian Bale does not officially win Le Mans, the talented person Lee Iacocca helped hire.
This is the point of living in C-world. It is the reality we live in. Many people will be shocked to discover how untalented and downright mediocre many of the best compensated and most influential people in our society are.
This phenomena that I challange ordinary working class people to go out and debunk, is largely due to the lack of social mobility - (for example, and the methodology may be somewhat dubious) we get headlines like "The Wealthy in Florence Today Are the Same Families as 600 Years Ago" and just think about it...
If you got rich, and had some kids, and some of them were complete pendejos or coƱos but you find yourself strangely attached to them despite your generational wealth, you might set them up with some bullshit business to ostensibly run as a hobby while consulting with an A-student of Accounting and Financial Planning to lock up ASSETS in a trust that can support them despite a COMPLETE ABSENCE OF BUSINESS ACCUMEN without them ever being able to sell off the very assets that generate the income that will support them and their stupid children and stupid grandchildren and finance their many divorces and unwillingness to pay child support for generations to come.
You'd do it. They have done it, for centuries.
The C-Curse Gets Worse: Nested Mediocrity and Subculture-Conformity
Something that I was slow on the uptake with, and hopefully it's not news to you, dear reader, was that our schooling system is I infer designed to test for conscientiousness and particularly industriousness, not intelligence.
So I implore you not to get bogged down in C-student being limited to school grades I choose it because of the ambiguity of mediocrity. I'm going to invoke tertiary study now but I am not talking about grades and not just because RMIT continues to use A+ to DNS grades while Melbourne University uses an overwrought esoteric H1A, H2B grading system.
I'm now talking about IQ, because by tertiary education specialization has begun in earnest. People do humanities, social sciences, hard sciences, technical disciplines and pure wank by University, and tend to further specialize by 2nd year after spending a year doing broad disciplinary subjects like Econ101, Acct101, Mktg101 etc.
IQ or "G" becomes more meaningful as a kind of predicter at how well a Law student might do understanding medicine vs a Medical student understanding law. It will likely be less predicted by their academic grades but by their relative IQs at that point.
I remember hearing roughly contemporary to my first time through University, some stat like the average Australian IQ was 107, but the average University students IQ was 127 or something, a whole standard deviation higher or there abouts (I am a C-student at probability).
This I think in practice, is one of life's cruelties. Because tertiary education brings together a bunch of people who likely were king dick of their academic pool and puts them into a smaller pool where they are likely merely average or below.
Indeed, because our tertiary selection process favors superiority over excellence - superiority being relative and excellence being a threshold. It is very likely that for some people in some disciplines, they are merely mediocre in intelligence, but on campus, the dumbest people there.
Adding to the cruelty is what keeps me up at night, the Dunning-Kruger effect, which roughly states that if you are the dumbest person on campus, you are also less likely to notice you are the dumbest person on campus.
Now it is time, finally, for this post to reject the null-hypothesis of Hitler's Law, a Law I coined which states:
"The longer one of tohm's blog-posts runs for, the probability he will invoke Lebron James approaches 1."
Lebron James is likely an NBA all-time great. I will concede that much. He is a fascinating case, because while he has tallied some impressive stat totals over his now 21 year professional career, including being by far the NBAs all time leader in turnovers with 5,459, he is among the all-time greats what I would call aggressively mediocre.
He is the athletic embodiment of Billy Conneley's joke:
"You know, I've been thinking about you a lot lately and you're a cunt. You've always been a cunt and in all likelihood you always will be a cunt. As a matter of fact, if they were giving a prize for World's Biggest Cunt, you'd probably come second."
"Second? Why wouldn't I come first?"
"Because you're a cunt."
Truly, Lebron James is the Ford of NBA greats. His ability, in theory to play all 5 positions, means he isn't in any discussions like "who's the greatest point guard?" "who's the greatest shooter?" "who's the greatest center?" "who's the greatest rim-protector?" "who's the greatest shot-blocker?" etc.
He is theoretically in the GOAT debate, artificially restricted by a heavily invested NBA and NBA media, as though there is a contest between Lebron and Michael Jordan, an Orwellian position where 2+2=7 somehow. Yet Lebron has never been the best player in the NBA at any point of his long occassionally somewhat lustrous career. Early he was dominated by Kobe Bryant and Tim Duncan. His super team routed by Dirk Nowitzki's Also-ran all-stars of the previous generation, then eclipsed by the GSW dynasty of Steff Curry for his prime-late-prime years, before his deadweight stat-padding years on the Lakers saw Giannis then Jokic overtake him as greatest player in the world on their antithesis super-team no-help small market teams as Anthony Davis carried him on ice-skates uphill while killing coaches and smearing HOFer teammates Russel Westbrook, and the aforementioned AD, soon to be Luca Doncic.
I think there's likely a real debate as to whether Lebron is better than Hakeem "the Dream" Olajuwon. Of which, Lebron probably loses, once you factor in the misfortune that Hakeem's career overlapped Michael Jordan's, and Hakeem is most likely the center I would compare to current best-in-the-world Nikola Jokic.
But this is the thing, by the time you are debating NBA players, let alone all-time-great NBA players, you are dealing with a level of nested mediocrity akin to the Guinness World Record holding most nesting of Babushka Dolls.
The "White Mamba" Brian Scalabrine who averaged 3 points per game over his career famously said:
"I am closer to Lebron, than you are to me." ~ The White Mamba, producing a greater philosophical legacy than Lebron James in one sentence.
Which is to say, statistically speaking it is likely that the greatest athlete you ever personally know, was nowhere near good enough to go pro in any sport of sufficient popularity.
(Again as a Balifornian, I have to make this qualifier, as I, the HS cross country captain of my small school was not in the top ten runners in my age group at the interschool competition. BHS by contrast had so many strong runners, that they did not even take the interschool comp seriously, playing on the playgrounds adjacent to the courses during the event and still beat me to a man. Their third strongest runner would go onto win an Olympic Gold Medal, because he realized he couldn't compete in long-distance running even at a state level and switched to walking. That school's prodigy, a freaky skeletal kid as far as I am aware, never made it to representing Australia nationally.)
Another cruelty of life then, is that the field keeps getting spread as you pursue superiority such that all but the tiniest few, will forever be C-students, as Lebron James is, always has been, and ever will be, in the NBA hall of fame. He spends millions allegedly on his body every year, so that at age 40 he can stand blowing on his hands, or complaining to a ref as his team rushes back to play 4-on-5 defense. I cannot imagine what he spends per year to keep himself artificially in, and losing, the GOAT debate.
I believe this Nested mediocrity is called the Peter Principle and it's kind of a crueller form of natural selection, because at least with natural selection - you get put out of your misery. Whereas with nested mediocrity you live out your misery, and likely reproduce your children into that misery.
At which point, I need to then switch contexts from nested mediocrity to the adjacent concept that I'm sure works on the same fundamental mechanics - Subculture conformity.
So you work in hospitality or a call center or maybe you now hang out with other Ubereats/Door Dash/Deliveroo gig workers in front of a local McDonalds and shoot the shit as you await the opportunity to deliver takeaway to a C-student full time office worker, time poor and lazy because their only career strategy is based entirely on presenteeism.
One of them, you find yourself respecting and admiring because of their unique self-expression. They don't dress like the rest of you, look at the same shit on their phones in downtime as the rest of you, they maybe even read an actual book. They are the most remarkable and unique person you know, and you feel somewhat privileged to have a friend like them, you consider it a perk of your shitty job.
Months pass and you both survive the natural attrition rates of your shitty jobs, and your unique colleague invites you somewhat sheepishly to their first-year art show. You go along, feeling self conscious wearing your seasonally-approved cut of jeans, cool conventional sneakers and clean graphic tee stepping onto an arts campus at night and walking into a show where...you discover everyone dresses, talks and acts like your friend.
No longer a unicorn literal they are just like all the other horses with the shift of context. Even the output of their distinct and unconventional mind is completely indistinguishable from the art exhibits of their peers.
Depending on where the art-scenes are in terms of the minimalist-maximalist cycle, they likely all look like this or this. Both examples taken from Exactitudes:
Started in 1994 in the streets of Rotterdam, this overarching and on-going project portrays individuals that share a set of defining visual characteristics that identifies them with specific social types. Be it Gabbers, Glamboths, Mohawks, Rockers or The Girls from Ipanema, Versluis and Uyttenbroek’s extremely acute eye allows them to discern specific dress codes, behaviours or attitudes that belong and characterise particular urban tribes or sub-cultures. Once they recognise an individual that fits the characteristics of a given group, they invite such person to be photographed at the studio with the only requirement of wearing the very exact same clothes s/he was wearing at the time they first encountered. ~ Taken from Exactitudes "About" page.
Exactitudes really use a methodology that isn't necessarily water-tight, to replicate the phenomena articulated in Monty Python's "Life of Brian"
Brian: "You're all individuals!"
Crowd (together): "Yes we are all individuals"
Individual: "I'm not..."
Crowd (together): "Shhhhh..."
While I don't have the direct experience myself, I imagine that this same manifestation of C-studentism, nested mediocrity, nested-normalization, is the constant bane of advertising firms. "We want to stand out so we came to you creatives. We want something like the gorilla-playing drums Cadbury ad." "Okay, well, you sell mostly goulash, how about we have two old hungarian ladies wrestling in goulash, weird, engaging, memorable." "Yeah wow! You guys really are creative, but we were thinking something more like a drummer in a gorilla suit playing the drums, like the Cadbury ad."
In which sense, subculture conformity mechanically is a movement away from the norm, but not too far from the norm. Hence the mediocrity drift of things like sleeve tattoos and neck tattoos. Whereas a unique individual wouldn't seek to move away from the norm, but from the population or sample.
It is also likely to be a manifestation of the Dunning-Kruger effect, in terms of self expression. If you want to be unique, it is very easy to not know how much there is to know about precedents of self expression. So people wind up not being unique, but conforming to a "unique" aesthetic, that changes constantly but has in the past two decades involved tramp stamps, fedoras, ugly sweaters, bicycle-frame glasses, bum-bags/fanny packs, 8 seasons of involuntarily writing material for Portlandia, griege attire, cultural appropriation from Japan, Korea and now Mexico.
It's hard to describe comprehensively, being fundamentally dynamic yet perennially tedious, in my own intellectual shorthand, I call it the "adolescent impulse" which is to say, adolescence was, for much of the 20th century post invention of the transistor radio, a period in which children migrated away from identifying with their family to awkwardly figuring out an individual identity. It likely manifested as going from adult-oriented to peer-oriented, hence kids start doing things like dressing, ostensibly, by their parents to dressing themselves.
If however they succeed at adolescence, they become adults, and here we get a perpetual push-pull, because the next class of adolescents need to differentiate themselves from adults like their parents and adults like you. Hence, the migration away from the norm becomes the new norm.
The cachet of going to Japan loses its cachet and hence you have to find somewhere else to go to be interesting by looking to your peers, so you switch from Osaka to Oaxaca. Until that inevitably collapses.
Because the sad fact is, there will always be more people who want to be interesting, than are interesting. Most people, indeed the vast majority of people seem to be fundamentally unqualified to be interesting. Hell I don't know if I have the qualifications to be interesting, and the fact that you have read this far most likely means a person who is not very interesting is reading the writing of someone who is not very interesting.
Monkey-see-Monkey-do
This is my best guess at the fundamental principle underlying C-ciety. Blessedly but annoyingly, I've already written it up. But you don't have to go read a whole other blog post on my badly outdated html script. I'll do a brief recap.
It's basically this: I think about how easy it is for me a human of most likely average intelligence to trap a dog with intelligence comparable to a 3-6 year old child, in an inescapable situation. It's not just that unlike the velociraptor most dogs can't operate a door knob, it is the ease with which I can repeatadly trick a dog into entering the same inescapable room until I see fit to let them in or out.
Granted, Usma, my mexican terrier could easily get me up off my feet to slide open the metal mesh door onto our courtyard at will with the deployment of a simple scratch, often times I suspect, just to enjoy her power over me, to get me up and out of my chair, but hopefully you get my point.
Why then, don't the smartest people just obliterate people everyone not quite as smart and down, out of the gene pool. Why isn't the flynn effect more pronounced?
Likely there's multiple explanations, the ones at the limits of my limited imagination being -
the smartest people often foil eachother, rather than cooperate. cancelling out their mutual advantage.
the smartest people are randomly distributed more-or-less throughout the population, whereas opportunity (power and influence) is hoarded by the wealthy. (we don't live in a meritocricy)
survival of the kindest supersedes in social mammals, the selective benefits of intelligence, such that most intelligent people don't have any drive to destroy competitors for resources.
The world is just too complicated for IQ or g to be a sustainable competitive advantage anyway because it only accounts for 20% of outcome.
But one I suspect is the big-one is "monkey-see-monkey-do" which is to say, when anyone figures anything out, most of the time, the solution is easily duplicated.
C-students everywhere, in every context just copy what the smart people are doing, so the half-life of advantage is incredibly small. Granted this can backfire:
And in terms of nested mediocrity, I myself mostly pass off other's opinions as my own, I just go further than the smartest person I know, to like books and public intellectuals like Chomsky and Nassim Nicholas Taleb and Kobe Bryant and Bill Russell.
In many ways, that's what learning is, hence most high school Physics graduates know more about physics than Isaac Newton did.
This is where I'm taking monkey-see-monkey-do and applying the very useful dichotomy of "excellence" vs. "superiority" he elaborates on in the interview.
We live in a world based on superiority. This is in many ways the allegory of the bear, which may be an actual biblical allegory but I'm referring to the guy who hearing the bear's roar, puts his running shoes on and his companion asks him "you think you can outrun a bear?" and the guy says "I don't have to outrun a bear, I just have to outrun you."
Superiority is relative, and as such it means you and I for example, cannot both be superior. Excellence is a threshold, it is absolute, furthermore it is dependent on producing a social good. One cannot be excellent at something that is bad.
What has me thinking about C-students lately, is business advice. See, I'm still processing the trauma of changing from casual employment to full-time. You might think that this revolves around having to get out of bed in the AM and commute during rush hour. My metabolic cycles adjusted relatively quickly.
No the skunked-trauma I am referring to, is that of going from underemployment to overemployment, both align only in the sense that one struggles to keep up good work. But when you are casual, you work hard, where in full time, often you have to work hard to get any work done at all, or work hard at finding enough work to do. So far I am succeeding, and a big part of the motivation is that my memory is fresh of what hard work feels like.
But when you take a lunch break knowing nobody is watching a clock to chase you down if you go more than two minutes over the collectively bargained break time allowance, you can feel kind of sad. A kind of ongoing survivors guilt that you have seen behind the curtain and know that a bunch of remarkably unproductive C-students (not singling out anyone in particular, and not necessarily excluding myself) collectively and systematically apply pressure to another group of C-students to be unreasonably productive, until they burn out, to be replaced.
This though, is just one aspect, the other prominent aspect of life behind the curtain that somewhat evokes trauma, is the almost random way in which one student can be receiving quite a large distribution of resources whereas others are stuck on the bread line. A lot of this, if not most of this, is the endurance of feudalism, why, while I suspect I'd find a bunch of problems with methodology, I would never be surprised to find generational wealth can persist for 600 years,
Most of the rags-to-riches-to-rags stories we might hear as we progress through life, are likely largely noise. Some social mobility is luck, some is crime, but most is economic growth. Unsustainable economic growth.
As such, most of our economy is C-students transacting with other C-students, and this is WAY unappreciated. I need to write about overemployment, that I am thus far successfully avoiding, by mostly sheer luck, but yes, I need to for my own sanity.
The thing is, in practice, holding down a job is finding a context in which you are a B-student, and then creating value for C-students. I suspect this will be the defining trait of consulting firms that sell Lean Manufacturing, 6 Thinking Hats, Matrix management, The Paperless Office, E-commerce, Internet Advertising, Online recruitment ... Agile management, AR, VR, the Metaverse, Blockchain and now "AI" will boil down to. In the kingdom of the blind - the one eyed man is king etc.
I need to stress however, the pertinance of C-students, versus average IQ. IQ is context independent (largely it still has linguistic vs geometric components or whatever) A C-grade is context dependent. Such that, industries that tend to attract broad-context A students like Law and Medicine, will still be populated largely by C students when you come to the ever evolving consultancy products for sale - from Snake Oil panaceas to AI.
AI is interesting, because it's big theoretical selling point is productivity. Something easy to sell to C-students it appears. Why? because while at a C grade, what is known and unknown is at max ambiguity, reliably C-businesspeople in particular, are in a form of upbeat denial as to how great a problem overemployment already is.
I may as well commit here, that I think AI is a bubble. It tickles all my marketing senses as being a load of hot air. I would wager, if I knew how and had sufficient assets to go short, that the hype cycle will collapse not into reality but oblivion.
The whole thing seems like a super expensive way to reinvent Clippy. So you know unambiguously where I tentatively stand.
My suspicion is that most of the sales, such as they are, are as Ed Zitrow points out, made by people who fill their days writing and reading emails, and now there's a thing that can somewhat accurately summarize emails.
The thing is, that those emails most likely function as a solution to the wicked problem of OVEREMPLOYMENT. Which is to say, exactly what was predicted by Keynes in his essay "On the Economic Opportunities of Our Grandchildren" minus the opportunities being realized, and the actual outcome as described by David Graeber in his essay "On Bullshit Jobs" which build's on Keynes' essay.
Namely, anyone in say Australia, presently holding down a full-time job, likely has a very expensive housing arrangement eating up most of their disposable income. They have big financial obligations that will eventually force them to lose their generational wealth, as housing and schooling become ever more expensive and late-in-life care will be financed by what wealth they do manage to accumulate.
Furthermore, the increase in asset prices like housing has been driven in Australia by increased private sector debt, not economic growth despite economies world-wide becoming enormously more productive, because that hasn't translated into real-wage growth.
Those opinions, based in sanguine fact, are taken from Gary Stevenson and Yanis Varoufakis. As such, every full time employee has a really strong incentive to merely survive, by never letting on that they are overemployed and as a result tremendously unproductive.
Most offices, long before surveillance software, adapted means by which to use "activity" as a proxy for "productivity" you write emails so that when the boss walks passed, it looks like you are doing something, you have meetings because they kill time and people assume you are meeting to discuss something of import and consequence. This opinion I take from Cal Newport.
So what I'm describing as the wicked problem endemic to C-world or C-ciety, is that wages are linked to hours, not value (especially not value in terms of social goods) vestigia from the industrial revolution. Full time employees cannot drop their hours, without dropping their wages, something they literally cannot do because they have financial obligations based on their full-time wage.
The real shit-kicker though, is that C-ciety spend so much time and effort - fucking eachother up. It's hard to be productive as a B-A-student, because C-students send you emails and schedule meetings. C-students are also trying to escape their terrible overemployment situation by aspiring to higher wages, and most of them resort to competing for those higher wages by increasing their activity over even more hours. Something that can seem justified because all their activity makes it so hard to get work done.
Then you wind up with all these C-managers, not to be confused with C-suite as in the "Chief something Officer" roles. I mean middle-managers, those too useful to fire, too useless to trust with real responsibility.
These are professional disruptors that make overemployment work. The people who make it almost impossible in many organizations to get any work done during 9-5. I am taking this opinion from a TED talk I can't be bothered to track down, but I believe it is backed up by some data, even if it is survey data.
Japan has famously, excelled since the 1980s at voluntary overtime. They also famously, have one of the world's least productive workforces, with going on 3+ decades of stagnation. Virtually untouchable stock index by value investors.
Peter Drucker admired much about Japanese business practices, but he ultimately could not recommend them, and though he did not put it in these terms, it's more-or-less because Japan puts all the C-students onto busy work, and render them wholly irrelevant. Even in the heydays of the Economic Miracle and the Bubble Years.
So why the fuck would you try to build autonomous software to increase the productivity of a mostly overemployed workforce? The problem isn't productivity, its pricing and has been for a long time.
Conclusion
The C-World is the antithesis of the conspiracy theory. It basically bets against intelligent design, it may well be the foundation of Hanlon's razor. It is the very distressing and uncomfortable idea that people like Australians can be incredibly wealthy, with some of the largest houses on earth and best quality of life, and largely have no idea what they are doing.
It is the uncomfortable reality, that just because somebody pulls up to your office in a BMW, tailored suit, hair transplants and enamelled teeth, they may be completely insolvent and about to drag you with them into a financial black hole.
It is the disturbing notion that the internet set up an ant-mill particularly apt if you like me, stole opinions from Julia Galef, but stupidly, forget to pass them off as your own, where Soldiers incurously defend their territory, including intellectual ones, and now the blind simply follow the blind, because all the C-student monkeys use google to find C-student monkeys to teach them what they already think they know.
Like maybe you, who stumbled across my C-student worldview because you searched for Julia Galef, James Maynard Keynes, Gary Stevenson, Yanis Varoufakis, Nassim Nicholas Taleb, Noam Chomsky, Billy Connelly or "cunts".
I have this idea that I want to turn into a thing, some thing, that I've been testing and refining for quite some time.
The idea is "Sell Me A Landlord" where I try to get someone to pitch to me, the valuable service of a landlord.
In my mind, this seems like a really simple exercise, so what has been the result of stress-testing it so far?
Most people I challenge to sell me a landlord, find the concept unintelligible. Like really smart people, cannot comprehend the idea. This is not to say that they do not have a crack at it, but inevitably they wind explaining to me why I want to buy instead of rent.
In current iterations I set it up like this:
I have $2 million dollars in cash, so if I want I can buy a house.
I am moving to a town where I have a ten-year employment contract, and I've got a family so we need a place to live.
An alternative to buying a home to live in, is renting one.
What are the advantages of having a landlord?
Now, I wouldn't ask of people anything I wouldn't do myself. I do think there are likely going to be scenarios where having a landlord is a service of value. For one, in a University town or area, where there's a population that only are going to live there for 3-4 years, they may drop out or transfer and signing some leases to sharehouse is preferable to buying and selling a house.
The other, is Aged-care facilities, where companies do literally sell the landlord as valuable service except I don't think anyone thinks of it that way, but aged-care facilities are often saying "come live in our house, we've got nurses, water aerobics instructors, arts and craft, carpet bowls, a gym we maintain, really great services so come live and pay rent here."
But you'll notice from my scenario, that I've eliminated those two scenarios. This is a presumably healthy and mobile person in the middle of their working part of their lifecycle.
For example, in my locale a specific service that advertises, and makes a case as to why I should consume their services are funeral homes:
A woman's touch. Also, tax accountants:
They don't miss a thing. Also, lawyers:
No challenge too great. Also, companies that actually build homes:
Why indeed live anywhere else? Also, companies that lend money to buy a home:
Yeah don't just ask your bank. But you never see ads for people saying "come live in my surplus housing, I'm a great landlord, here are all the wonderful services I provide..."
Even on facebook pages where sharehouses advertise rooms for rent to potential housemates, the posts tend to focus on amenities and maybe nearby features before listing a fuck-tonne of demands about shit a successful housemate will be expected to tolerate or refrain from. Then 60 to 120 people apply regardless because everyone is so desperate and it costs nothing to apply.
Why does it matter?
The point of the exercise is, that if you can't make a sales pitch for a landlord, then you can't justify landlords providing a valuable service or social good.
Hilariously, everyone who I've challenged to this hypothetical scenario, has wound up, quite quickly trying to convince me to buy instead of let.
Most recently, I was presented with a very clever argument to point out that the difference between owning and renting on cash flow is so pronounced, that provided a tenant channels the savings into an investment (index fund, government bonds maybe even) then they are not at a loss compared to owning. He then countered this pitch (the landlord is assuming the investment risk for you) with the argument that most tenants don't invest the savings, they spend it, where a mortgage forces ordinary citizens to commit their income into what is essentially a forced savings scheme. This was very similar to what I have heard Scott Pape say.
But I cannot say that landlords are not a valuable service because of the intelligibility problems I have come across. It literally does not occur to Australian's that a landlord is a profession, and a service at that. I am more confident in saying that based on my experiences thus far, to most Australians a landlord is simply a fact of life, and landlord is not so much a job title, as a title like the "Laird" of established titles.
The overwhelming sentiment I get is that landlords generally dislike their tenants and tenants dislike their landlords. Almost like it is a dirty job that somebody has to do.
I live in a district where the Liberals (Australia's conservative major party) are campaigning hard, not with respect to the fact that they lost a long held safe seat of former PM and longest serving PM Robert Menzies to an Independent in the Teal wave because of long standing frustration and dissatisfaction and are now trying to show the constituents that they have listened and learned and want another chance. But by spending a lot of money and putting a kid up who is some descendent of a former Victorian premier, running an absurd scare campaign and hitting non-sensically vacuous talking points.
One of which is that they are going to address housing affordability. This is incongruous though with the central complaints of what I infer to be their prime voter-base, complaints about how high land tax is.
When I first heard these grumbles I got fucking curious, because this is something organizations I have been involved in have been lobbying for, for a long time, and I mean over a century. So I looked up the rates that are causing so much ire.
Acknowledging that I am a weirdo, with beliefs on the fringe, I don't think a land tax rate comparable to our marginal income tax rates are outrageous. Particularly since I would be advocating that land tax replace income tax, so you cut taxes on wages, replace the lost revenue with land tax.
But putting myself in the head of an ordinary, largely economically illeterate land owner, what kind of rate would I expect to be outrageous? something between 8-10% would get someone with a property portfolio clutching at pearls I reckon.
If you clicked through that link though, you would know that what has landlords up in arms, is a land-tax of 1%, and it more-or-less trebles to 3% or maybe 4% on your beach-house. The term used is "absentee owner surcharge" and I will plead ignorance as to whether this applies to properties let by the owner in the case of an "investment" property.
What has the landed gentry up in arms, really is actually the price of houses. Because a $30,000 tax bill sounds large to a peanut like me who doesn't own a $3M property. But this is less than a medium wage. If somebody sitting on a $3M assett can't afford to kind-of-pay for a part time civil servent, why does the tax burden fall on my wages and 10% of my goods and services consumption. $90K sounds like a big tax bill, until you realize that that is for a landlords spare $3M property that they use for 14 weekends a year during daylight savings time. They are only paying $50K on the $5M house they live in.
Housing is considered affordable when the cost of housing is less than 30% of your pay, I'm not sure if this is take home or net pay. Australia has pretty good salaries in general, but this is largely because our overvalued property prices have forced them up, like the casual wage is somewhere between $24.10 an hour, which compared to California's $16.50 USD is roughly on par with the world's 5th largest economy. (Australia is in the G20, not the G7) and many people earn more than the minimum. Australia also has "casual loading" which is intended to compensate for the lack of sick leave and annual leave under that employment arrangement.
Holding those wages constant though, if the median house price was set to one where a 30 year mortgage at 6.5% interest was = to 30% of the median take home pay, I calculate that an affordable median house price being $447K.
In a country where the Australian median wage in an urban center like Melbourne could be used to purchase an affordable house and pay it off over 30 years would put the median house price at $447K and the land tax would be $5K.
Now the thing being, that if a landlord is not in fact a service that anyone values then why the fuck does Australian tax policy in fact, encourage people to invest in housing, which is to say buy a business where they can provide the services of a landlord?
That's the relevance. I won't go into negative gearing, capital gains tax concessions and the fact that a landlord can break a lease contract to enable them to sell their investment asset at any time (with whatever the notice is that tenants have to get the fuck out and find somewhere else to live nearish their job and schools and whatever.)
I started a new job, which resulted in offices in the CBD. I am once again, being chafed by a suit and this means I haven't quite figured out the logistics of riding into downtown, so I train. Walking through the CBD I am struck by the almost ubiquitous and instantaneous adoption of "wide-leg" jeans.
Part of me has been awaiting this for a long time. I am old enough to recall that australians called the "low-rise" jeans "hipsters." The look attributed to Alexander McQueen from a mid 90s show he did, but I feel more accurately should be attributed to Mariah Carey who cropped her own jeans for the film-clip for "heartbreaker" released in 1999, ready for the mousekateers of Britney Spears, Christina Aguilera and whoever else to usher in a brief era of muffin topping and exposed arse cracks for Y2K fashion.
Women's jeans would go high-rise again by 2008 but remained skinny, and by then hipsters had also arrived and the general post-Bush pretentiousness of the Obama years. Obama himself was not a style icon, but next to the indie-film "Napoleon Dynamite" the tone of his administration was the biggest influence that would prevail in urban centers until pretty much yesterday.
Like, I don't like skinny jeans and even less, I don't like the lack of variation we have seen. Terrible cuts like bell-bottoms and the carpenter jeans are fine because they will be gone in a season or two. But jeans have been stagnant, at least to my ability to perceive it, for a long time.
So now, that the contouring jeans are finally and quite abruptly gone, how do I feel? Well, mixed.
What is already and always alarming, is the speed of adoption. I feel it safe to assert that Australian fashion, even that driven by the growing Asian fashion infleunce, is not set in the southern hemisphere. Whatever process lead to the adoption of the wide-leg jean in 2025 likely happened 6 months ago in the northern hemisphere and may have been battled out over their winter such that Australia just accepts the fait accompli literally the moment the seasons officially change.
I assume "wide leg" jean is a response to a more spontaneous and quiet revolution that was the workman's or carpenters jeans. A cut that probably looks fine when sandwiched between a tool belt and steel-toed workman's boots, but I feel looked objectively terrible on everyone I saw wearing them. The most notable and pronounced aspect of the look being how they fell away from the arse and proceeded toward the ground like two PVC pipes stood upright next to eachother.
My best speculation was that they had been appropriated by women tired of the post-J-Lo-peak-Kardashian emphasis on having a big round ass. No more jeans that looked great if you had a shelf or a dumper, but also left nothing to the imagination if your arse was flat and the cheeks migrated down the back of your legs, something men with shapeless arses also likely suffer from too, to a much lesser extent. Much like the low-rise or "hipster" jeans of the 2000s, that which was adopted by women was eventually adopted by men.
From this, the designer labels responded with "wide-leg" for the 2024-25 winter season, and they do at least, not look terrible like the fucking workmans jeans that it should be said, managed to flatter nobody while giving no suggestion of irony, just a white flag of surrender. I'm sure they are very comfortable. Something that struck me was that seemingly every label was on top of this, as a brief perusal of Levi's, Calvin Klein, Uniqlo, Guess and Ksubi were all on top of the "trend" with products ready to sell for the trending.
This coordination is what leaves me uncomfortable, like having to pass through the walking dead of retail, regardless of whether the style is an improvement or not. The simplest explanation is that "the industry" caused the trend, supply created demand. Now I'm sure there was some attenuated process whereby the industry has consultants that were called "cool hunters" back at the turn of the century and served as protagonists for William Gibson's "Pattern Recognition" book, also written up in Malcolm Gladwell's tipping point, where they go and see what cool kids somewhere organically innovate and then mass market it - like around the turn of the century how cool hunters determined "Valley girls" were appropriating the Cholo sandals and next thing you know Private school girls in rural Victoria are wearing adidas sandals despite to this day never having heard of Selina.
For me my reaction is straight up Xenophobia, the idea of buying jeans to fit-in does not compute. Yet people clearly live this way, rendering me a stranger in a strange land right at home.
How long does a laptop last? Mine is getting on 7 years old, but performance wise I suspect 4 years is a long time to hang onto a laptop. How long does a pair of jeans last me? In my case anywhere between 10 to 26 years. I don't really understand the mind that would buy a new pair of jeans every year. At most, I can understand people who wear their jeans a lot, and so are not going to get by on one pair, maybe buying a new pair every year to replace the oldest pair whose pockets are worn through by their house keys and the zipper increasingly catches or breaks and the hems are all scuffed and frayed and the crotch seem is going to break any day now.
In this sense, the stability of a more or less conventional straight leg, high crotch jean where "baggy" is what I would call regular and regular is what I would call "skinny" and "skinny" is what I would call stockings, has been great for that.
Because of the context and timing I was exposed to the not so much trend as pandemic of wide-leg jeans, my initial impression was "oh cool the 90s are back" as Calvin Klein are inaccurately marketing their cut. Very quickly my acute sensitivity though was "something is off" it wasn't quite the 90s.
Part of it, no doubt, is racism. The melbourne downtown, particularly the retail parts of it, are post-covid a Asian student ghetto. All of my experiences of Asia, is that when they appropriate and adapt western aesthetics, they never think to just ask. So we get weird and often wonderful mutations, like the Japanese putting chunks of potato on pizza which I'm sure was based on somebody misinterpreting a photo of a hawaiian pizza.
I'm impressed with my sensitivity though, because almost everyone was layered so I couldn't see any of the jeans above the thighs. The geometry was just off though that I could see it tapering out instead of scrunching. Yes, it is right not to call "wide leg" jeans "baggy jeans" because they are somewhere between baggy and bell bottoms. A facsimile of 90s jeans, I suspect seeking to address the inherent problems of low-rise or, for a purest like me - sagging.
Why now? Fixie Alpaca Lips
A quick check of another Blog almost as old as mine: Bike Snob NYC and certainly more successful than mine ever has been and ever will be, I found it unsearchable to find when his "pistadex" indicated the fixed gear bicycle bubble burst. I did find this post though that alluded to the "boom-bust" of fixed gears in the early 21st century in the past tense. So I take it as more or less confirmed that the fixed gear is dead.
In my heart I already knew it, as soon as I got back from Mexico and started riding my own again, I saw pretty much nobody riding a single-speed. Melbourne single-speed bicycle specialty shop "Just Ride It" has moved out of Fitzroy/Collingwood. I have locked my bike up to numerous hoops in Smith st in the past year, I've never returned to find a fixed gear next to it.
I don't know what has killed it, I am guessing a combination of e-bikes and Ubereats, Deliveroo, Door Dash etc. you know, basically the human face of growing wealth inequality world wide. My best guess is that this new economy of serfdom basically crowded the hipsters out of the bike lanes. And maybe, people just got sick of watching someone on an e-bike zip uphill as they destroyed their knees and ankles climbing a hill in their one inappropriate gear.
But here's the thing, I think the fixie was intimately linked to the enduring staying power of skinny jeans for over a decade. Skinny jeans and bicycles are complementary - the sales of one drives the sales of the other.
I certainly manage to clear a top-tube in low crotch, but low crotch pants are not great for cycling. The big thing though is having the hem of your jeans chewed up by the bike chain and gear. Something that snugly cuffs your leg is desirable, and bicycles probably also drove the turned-up and rolled-up jeans trend.
With fixies gone though, and cycling something for the proles once again, I think this has allowed the space for the wide-leg, literally. E-scooters, and also EVs probably made a bunch of people finally shout Ya basta! at their winter bicycle commute to somewhere...and of course Covid killed the commute, so that certainly would have killed a lot of bicycles...
Anyway, this is all to say, that the industry has probably been itching for years to arbitrarily change "how they're wearing them" from skinny to baggy - just to increase sales, but couldn't because baggy wouldn't fly in a world where cycling was tre chic. But with people not cycling, at last, it is a dream come true. A style so different conformists have to buy it. Which would have been true of a style shift that involved turning the cuff up a bit, or a barely noticeable change in placement and number of distress tears.
Here at last is the psychological pressure to say "nobody is wearing jeans skinny anymore." Which is of course bunk. Women who look good in skinny jeans will have an attentional advantage over anyone wearing anything loose fitting. I mean, to spill the tea on the whole scam of fashion, I can testify that clothing cuts have never fooled me, I can tell who is attractive and who isn't whether you are wearing jeggings and a crop top or a moomoo and a hijab.
The main differentiation clothes maketh of the wearer is in telling me whether someone has a personality or not, first and foremost, and secondly what that personality might contain. It isn't as easy however, as just getting goth-vamp-rave gear and being "tada! interesting" because those looks to me are good indicators in the 21st century, of an absence of personality.
Anyway, let me head into more speculative territory...
Why now? Dad shoes?
A curious key weakness of a jean cut that bunches at the bottom, is that it deemphasizes shoes. The decline in popularity of fixed-gear bicycles is an objective fact. Survey the streets and their numbers are waaaaay down. The decline of the importance of footwear is a different story. Highly subjective.
Now again with my sensitivities, I noticed when I walk into Hype or Platypus franchises that sell sneakers and street shoes, that the color pallet is now in the Greige-range. Perhaps gone are the days of limited edition colour-ways, the chunky Dad-shoe NB sneaker reigns supreme, if it ever possibly can.
I basically missed this, and I feel no emptiness as a result. It's a stupid fucking fashion worn by idiots. What slapped me in the face like private boarding school genitals when I returned from Mexico to Australia, was that people were basically wearing cushions on their feet - most prominantly NB or HOKA, and I would still suggest that given our ageing population and the general disenfranchisement and disillusionment of the youth by an economy designed to transfer wealth from the young to the old to finance phase 1) lavish retirements and phase 2) expensive end-of-life care, the majority of the market are wearing dad shoes because they are dads and grandads.
That said, Asians seemed to wear designer dad shoes as some kind of rave-culture techwear, leading to a monochrome colour scheme that perhaps...perhaps paved the way to just obscure the whole thing with bell-bottomed jeans with a less severe, more graduated taper.
That speculation, being the least likely to be correct, is also to me the most interesting, because frankly so long as this cut persists - shoes don't matter. The only solution I can predict to keep consumption of both wide-leg jeans and footwear high, is a resurgance in high-tops, provided the correct way to wear the look, is to actually allow oversize clothing to bunch up at the ankle - which is how baggy jeans sit when sagging off the hips or cinched below the butt cheeks.
So let's wait and see if one trend drives another, or people save money on "statement" shoes for a little while.
Since dislocating my shoulders (which is a pertinent reminder to write a post called "rationalizing my own stupidity" and look, I've already derailed this post) and yes I mean "shoulders" plural or the technical term I learned "bilateral dislocation;" I have found the new habit of taking long evening walks. This will probably change now summer is behind us, but the seasonal transitions are not as well defined as our calendar.
I walk late at night, and I walk far. I most often listen to audiobooks, but as my concentration and attention continues to improve, I tend to lift heavier weights - attention-wise - by walking in serene silence.
The lateness allows me to see fauna I had never really observed because I did not hit Melbourne's interlaced trails at night for all the decades I've lived here. Maybe once or twice riding a bicycle home along an actual trail rather than the most direct grab-bag of streets between a gig-venue and my home, I would see a fox. But Melbourne's many parks, gardens and park-like spaces accommodate an abundance of foxes. There is also the majestic silent flight of owls. The dusk exodus of cockatoos and commute of bats are well known and well observed, as are possums who often leave testimony of their nocturnal life through the electrocuted corpses found beneath above ground powerlines around suburbia.
If I walk later, I see more foxes, owls, spiders in the middle of highly ambitious webs. If I leave earlier I see more dog walkers.
And every dog on a walk has a smile for me and I for them. Two evenings ago I came across a little buddy for whom I had to pull out my headphones to say hello. He was happy as a clam, wobbling and fumbling around on two extremely gimpy back legs with a kind of boundless oblivious energy that resembled a kid in a candy store.
As one does, I asked his owner "how old?" (En Mexico gentes preguntar "masculino o feminino?" de sus perritos.) and surprisingly he said "Three" and began to detail that they were 1.5 years into extensive rehab after spinal surgery, including hydrotherapy.
This, is love. One can look at a situation like this like a cautionary tale of the reverse lottery of dog ownership. Most people cannot just let a puppy die, the reverse lottery of dog ownership is to buy a dog (and the designer dogs can be quite expensive, breeders earn their keep on a single litter of puppies and pay for their house with one mother's total legal output) get attached and then discover yourselves in for medical bills.
Love is the attachment to your dog, and the simple reality that for $10,000 you can keep your dog around a little longer with some quality of life, and for $2,500 you can buy another dog, that merely has the potential to become your second or nth dog, but you will have a your-dog sized scar in your heart for the rest of your life.
For me though, though it sucks, love is what money is for. Yes, this is a post, and I know this is poor form, about economics.
Watch for example The Martian, where millions of dollars are spent to rescue Matt Damon from Mars, his crew who decide to resupply and form his rescue mission lose themselves a year of terrestrial living in order to risk a small window of opportunity to get Matt Damon back to Hollywood.
Think then, on all the other causes that money could be spent on, to save more human lives than Matt Damon. For a fraction of the cost food security could be given to populations suffering famine. Vaccines could be rolled out and diseases that kill children eliminated. A few thousand dollars could prevent hundreds of deaths from preventable mosquito born diseases.
But I think, The Martian works as a movie because we are not accountants and actuaries. We intuitively calculate the symbolic value of rescuing a stranded solitary human being on an alien planet, and most people would I think concur that it is worth the spend to expand our human frontiers in this way.
Nassim Nicholas Taleb in one of his books points out that during the Lebanese civil war, where people were being killed daily in violent armed conflict, the popular imagination was captured by an Italian girl who got stuck down a well.
I heard an argument from Cam Murray that persuaded me, at least, that Australia's superannuation should be repealed as a scheme, and I do focus here on one relevant argument, which is exactly the situation where you get a letter from your Superfund that tells you you have $20,000 and a vet tell you you need $6,000 for surgery for your dog or it dies. So you of course let your dog die, because there's nothing in the scheme that says you can access your super in these circumstances, you'll just have to wait 45 years to enjoy that $20,000 with which you can finally commission a memorial statue...or something.
(Other arguments against Super are that it is funded out of wage-rises, as in employers fund the contributions instead of giving pay rises. It helps grow wealth inequality, and most people should they have super use it to just pay down their mortgage and retire etc. etc.)
At which point, we can expand love beyond the love felt between man and dog, one of the purest and longstanding loves, despite like all forms of love, there being its perversions and betrayels in the specific. But the same goes for our lovers, our children, our family, friends, extended family.
This is what money is for, and I've monitored the exchange rates. In Mexico I heard of a particularly moving story where a woman we knew had a son get into a motorcycle accident. The local hospital said he would die if he was not transported to a hospital that can help him. In a country like Australia, this can arise for the uninsured if they need to be helicoptered to a big-city hospital from a remote area, because despite universal health care this does not cover ambulance services, and the ambulances that fly can hit you with a bill in the $100,000s. Btw ambulance membership is like 50 smackeroos a year and covers any and all bills.
Where was I? Blessed Mexico. Yes, so...[ugh] in Australia you would get the helicopter anyway, then declare bankruptcy and maybe have to sell your house. In Mexico, there's a good chance the house won't cover the cost of the IC ambulance transportation, so you get presented with "pay or die." scenarios. This mother was able to secure a loan from an In-law for some collosal sum that would be in Australian terms the vicinity of $100k, to be paid back...somehow. For this was not an investment opportunity, and even if it were a high risk one because there was so much to still do to save the son's life.
He was transported, some amputations and organ removals were made, an induced coma and I'm happy to report that he pulled through and to my knowledge is still alive to this day. It is entirely possible that somebody wound up financially ruined by this act of love, but the decisions made reflect well on everyone involved bar the state of Mexico.
That's but one example of the exchange rate. Desperate non-solutions to that of preserving our time on this planet and our opportunities to be in the vicinity of love include what an elderly Kerry Packer paid his long time helicopter pilot for his kidney to buy him a few more months of life, botox, ozempic etc.
I've heard many boomers remark and assert of their age cohort in general that the richest of them would give it all to be (our) age again. This remark I'm sure only holds under the assumption that such a transaction would be miraculous. Should rejuvenating technologies actually exist, I'm sure competition would drive the prices down, such that we would discover that boomers would stop short of giving it all to be my age or younger, and instead settle for helping some guy with a machine enough money to pay off his sportscar finances, or some guy with a machine made in China enough money to pay his rent for one week.
But if the Faustian pact was available, everything to be 21 again, I kind of wish boomers would take it, to gain an appreciation of how much youth is depreciated by the generational apartheid on assets. How I would love to see how an influx of 21 year olds entering the job market, who may know a lot more about financing a company and paying minimal income taxes, fare with their degrees from the 70s and early 80s held by a quarter of them, and their inability to type with ten digits over two, and their grasp of OSs, coding etc. hold up in an ultra-competitive job-market, especially when the devil now controls the majority of Capital.
I feel only the exceptionally successful boomers would have a chance. The rest, having a second wind of youth with which to truly experience the pleasures of meth, jenkem and bath salts.
And this brings me to the severity of the exchange rate, which is the how little respect we give for those who will fork over a fortune of money, literally the tokens of debt owed to them for work they have suffered through, for the love of puppy, or spouse, or child, or brother or sister.
This is, one of the first and last good points Brett Weinstein made: We have to look at the fate of benevolent firms.
We live in a world where many successful businesses' true competitive edge is a disregard for laws and regulations. They get around minimum wages by having workers work twice the hours they are paid for and so on.
The problem with the true price of love, are the people waiting, ready and willing to swoop in and take your house.
In this sense I am somewhat sympathetic to former worlds-richest-man and oil magnate Paul Getty, though I know him mostly through the onscreen depiction from "All the Money in the World" where when his grandson and namesake was kidnapped, first by people he had instigated in his own scheme, and eventually by the Calabrian Mafia, he declined to pay the ransom - out of consideration of the safety of all his other numerous grandchildren. He eventually paid an agreed sum equal to the maximum he could claim in taxes or on insurance or something. It was sizeable but relative to his wealth miserly, and his grandson's physical and mental health by then was irreversibly damaged.
But we really have no protection for people who choose for their own sake and for the extended, integrated network of loved ones, to choose love over money. There's no backstop where people can go bankrupt but for their assets their generational wealth, which even while being quite modest, under growing wealth inequality must be defended at all costs.
Now people waste exorbitant amounts of money all the time at the top end of town, forget about surgeries for sickly dogs. First class flights? The price point difference between a 9am flight from Melb to Sydney on Jetstar in roughly 5 weeks from today is $122 (with baggage allowance) to $1,094 for a Qantas business class flight same time same day. There just isn't the utility to be extracted from Business class in a roughly 3 hour flight. Sure there is then the lounge memberships, early boarding etc. and many wealthy people use charter flights in private jets.
Now the incremental utility grows with frequency of travel. It is fair enough that someone who has to fly for work a hundred times a year, be put in the peak comfort available. I'm also assuming that businesses get tax concessions for travel expenses like this, while keeping the financial assets like frequent flyer points becoming effectively public business infrastructure.
But there's also the car collecting, the country and town houses, the beach houses etc. and all the associated upkeep, the race horse part ownership etc. But can these low-utility excesses a) keep an even keel between people sacrificing all for love and b) be called a form of love of their own?
“I say that homosexuality is not just a form of sex, it's a form of love, and it deserves our respect for that reason.” — Christopher Hitchens.
Is love of limited run super and hyper cars a form of love that deserves our respect? If so, only in proportion. Certainly far less than the love of lovers, should be afforded to a love of things. With all but the most handcrafted by dead artisans, things, unlike your dog can be replaced by an identical thing. Whether new for old (like a new Lotus) or old for old (like a restored DeLorean).
Bringing me to a question that I have had an uncomfortable amount of time to ponder, for which I will have to establish a little context.
My oldest friend, chronologically, killed himself which is statistically, one of the most likely ways for a man to die, so I am by no means alone in having such a thing disrupt my life and sense of place in the universe nor even unusual. What was of tremendous consolation to me, was how I had interacted with my friend while he was alive. The Hitchens phrase above is one that he oft repeated, having gone to the effort of crafting it, but I draw it from his memoir Hitch-22 as my most recent hearing of it. In the same audiobook there was packaged an interview with the author, contemporary to publication of his audiobook, where he was asked "why now" and he remarked that many of his friends had paid him the compliment of suggesting it was too soon, and that he had much good work ahead of him. But Hitchens pointed out that one doesn't get to experience the advent of it being "too late" to write an autobiography on account of being dead.
In the same sense, whatever my friend's state of mind was when he ended his own life, somewhere in the biological building blocks of that mind was the certain knowledge that I loved him, that I had said what needed saying before it was too late. This is because, while certainly the worst loss I'd experienced in my life, it was not the first.
And here is the crux: I have observed people who live there lives, largely as habit (and I would too, were I secured enough) remarking about how a death can "put things in perspective" and I have no doubt they are experiencing the dizzying reorientation of how before the news they'd been consumed with some trivial task they were required to do at work.
What I generally observe though, is that for many the grieving process is merely a disruption to the habitual life. What most appear to do (and this may be an illusion of the alienating nature of grief) is process until they rediscover the reasons their habitual life formed in the first place.
Something like "the reason I care about the reconciling the weekly stock reports with the monthly stock reports is that I am paid to care, by my employer, and with that pay I secure the things my children need so they may one day have a job like mine that will allow them to provide for their children."
Which is to say, they gain some perspective, but not a sustainable one.
The question I was forced to ponder, was the debilitating effects of maintaining the kind of perspective that comes with grief. To truly realize that much economic activity, does not matter or at worst, is actually counterproductive to achieving love and life.
This is a perspective that is no doubt disquieting, but the reality we live in is one of FTX, Enron, LTCM, Theranos etc. People turned up to work at Enron, went through inductions including OH&S videos where they possibly were told technically they should change shoes in order to lift an archive box from a storage shelf, sexual harassment, they were given a desk and a swipe card to enter and exit buildings, a network login and an email, they received payslips and salary was deposited in their bank accounts and pension funds. They paid their taxes, and laboured away in various departments, all the while having no idea about the full implications of "Mark to Market" accounting that would enventually liquidate the entire firm and invalidate whole lifetimes of economic activity.
To be sure, many an innocent and unassuming productive worker at Enron likely paid down a mortgage and put their children through school through the attractive salaries offered and recieved. It was not a total waste of their lives, but the part of their life wasted was all that they produced for Enron. One has to chalk it up to a learning experience, but then the skills learned by doing useful work for an ultimately useless company carry the stink of the Enron brand to a resume, and job interviews are often decided in 40 seconds based on attire, demeanour, grooming, manner and punctuality before getting to the thorny question of whether you were caught up in the demise of Enron or a somewhat innocent drone.
An archetypal news story, I guarantee to recur so long as you are alive is "[Insert publicly listed company here] posts $x.x Bn losses" which means that the sum total culmination of effort exerted by workers in that company went toward delivering a service or product that more people didn't want or need than did.
The premise of "It's a wonderful life" is that Jimmy Stewart has one fucking job to deliver a fat wad of cash to the bank to avoid bankruptcy and forfeiture of assets and he fucks it up. He then wishes he'd never been born and an angel shows him what life would be like if he hadn't been, where he realizes the significant positive impact he has had and chooses to live.
The fact though for most of us, is that we are largely redundant. That in itself is fine, even with redundancy ultimately some component has to do the things that are of value. But in the recent 20th Century we had vast amounts of devestation and bloodshed - from the Trench Warfare of The Great War that ravaged Europe and fed a whole generation of young men into a meat grinder, where the Christmas day truce lasted so long military command had to force the soldiers to resume killing each other again. Then WWII that also had the Holocaust, through to the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, famines in India etc. Then there was Stalinism (~10 million, mostly famine and gulags and 1 million in political executions) and Maoism (40 to 80 million estimated dead best summed up in Maoism) , and if you are reading this, you are probably sitting in a place where you are more or less fine, with access to water and food, shelter and internet. Sorry to those of you who are homeless reading this on a phone plugged into a socket in a train station or shopping centre.
Happily in recent times, I am inclined to concur that my perspective is likely not debilitating. I have no problem with people acquiring what I should dub a modest wealth. And consistent with my views on The Martian, a truly talented athlete that can capture the imagination of so many and expand seemingly the frontiers of human possibility like Michael Jordan is probably as rich as I think a person should be, albeit this is restricted to the exorbitant wages paid to him by the Chicago Bulls that were so in excess of what anyone else in the NBA was paid, that they actually put in a wage cap that held until inflation allowed Steph Curry to earn Jordan's 90s money some 20 years later. Not the having children make shoes for $s and selling them for $$$s side that has made Jordan a billionaire.
And there's nothing wrong with billionaire's so long as they are paying taxes, taxes like someone would pay if they were paid a billion dollars for work, and not the sale value of the assets they hold, where they pay destabilizingly little tax.
The fact is, mental health is king. We experience our own lives subjectively, and the tragedy of meeting an unhappy and insecure rich person, is not just that their lack of perspective has wasted their lives, but needs must be concluded that they have likely wasted much of everyone else's lives that have invested in them. Perhaps somebodies can sometimes throw money at a person who lacks perspective so they can take it and make money for them while they spend their precious time achieving Eudaimonia but right up to the POTUS and DOGEUS down to the local well-healed nobody whose bones will be indistinguishable from all the other hairless apes, the king goes back into the box with all the other pawns and all that, who cannot shut up about how smart he is to have built a property portfolio to provide a service valued by nobody (in many cases literally nobody, because they are just sitting on and speculating on property prices) and leaving a legacy that will not have their great grandchildren even knowing their names.
And I am not driving at achievement culture as described by Byung-Chul Han in "The Burnout Society" as the alternative here. Because someone is likely to remember Musk and Trump in three generations time, assuming there's anyone here to remember, and Putin and Xi and whoever else too, are not examples to look to and their lives, despite their accomplishments all, look like they lack perspective. The lives of people who have risen to heights of influence that have placed them completely out of touch. No a life quite ordinary can be meaningful and rewarding, so long as it keeps the price of love firmly in perspective.
As I wrote the last few paragraphs, I could overhear one of my loved ones on a phone advocating for another of our loved ones. This same loved one recently had a birthday and we the family that were able gathered to celebrate it in a modest and intimate dinner with modest but delicious food and cake. I was coming off a particularly challenging week, one filled with disorienting ambivalence as I met some of the best and worst people to deal with all mixed up like the climbs and dips of a rollercoaster.
My aunt was a tonic after that week, to sit down with because she is good and decent and kind, and maybe these very qualities have lead to her being denied much in life, though there are other factors at play. The fact is I love her and she is worth loving.
My chief persistent pang (which is good to write because an ear would likely hear "pain" where it expects to hear it) is from my Mexican dogs, and yes, I'm circling in for a conclusion. Some conscious part of me understands how worthy of ridicule it is to build my life plans going forward about reuniting with our short-lived companions before they die, when dogs are a dime a dozen, or un peso por docena, but they are my dogs not in any legal sense, but in the attachment formed.
Yes, ironically, it was Usma that taught me there were more dogs to love after Bess, my companion of 15 years from childhood to prolonged adolescence. I know I can fall in love with another dog, but we already love eachother. And I know that dogs tend not to follow "absence makes the heart grow fonder" for their survival instinct are too strong, and they operate their affections more along the "what have you done for me lately" lines. But I am supremely confident it would take just a few hours before after a feed they want to curl up by me again, once again, in love.
Truly coming full circle on this long walk, yesterday on lunch break I happened across quite the opposite pairing of owner and dog. A healthy strapping dog in its prime, on the leash of a man who had severe burns covering at least 50% of his face. I don't know his circumstances, he was walking through the lawyer part of downtown, not in the student and shopper part sitting with a makeshift sign declaring him homeless.
But those debilitating injuries and scarring can't make life easy, probably not easier than mine, and it puts me in mind of all those homeless, those sleeping rough be it in Melbourne, Australia freq. world's most liveable city, or the streets of Mexico, and their animal companions, typically dog who no doubt increase donations by their mere presence, help keep them safe from molestation and assault at night and form a precious loving bond, unconditional but fragile.
Herein lies the perspective, worth maintaining - if you are homeless you get a pass. Life must be constant stress, so insecure. Everyone else, keep and defend your best energy for those you love. You may be giving work and career your all for those you love, but they don't get to experience your energy. They get to nurse your exhausted self while you recuperate. The economics says, you are not reaping the rewards of your productivity. Productivity has surged in the last 50 years and workers have seen none of the gains, beyond the cost reductions of technology.
The blind leading the blind is fine, provided your blindness isn't caused by shutting your eyes to remember your infrequently used pin number through muscle memory. If you can open your eyes and maybe lead a blind person instead to secure love and mental comfort.